Machine translated · For reference only
Why Is It Getting Harder for Indie Games to Secure Funding? A Look at How Investors Choose Games, Using "Gardens" as an Example
Russell · 文化与观点
This article is based on a discussion from Remap’s episode “The Future of Indie Game Funding.” Funding amounts and industry observations are presented as stated in the episode.
What criteria must a game meet to attract investment?
An outstanding team, unique ideas, and a clear market positioning—these are the elements that typically appear in the answers. But in reality, even experienced teams may struggle to secure funding, while projects that haven’t yet revealed their full business model can still attract large rounds of investment one after another. There is always an inexplicable gap between the quality of a project and its funding outcomes.
In this episode of Remap, Austin Walker, who is currently involved in raising funding for original games, offered a perspective: Securing funding requires developers to transform their creative vision into a demonstrable experience and find people willing to believe in it and help bring it to life. This process is also influenced by the funding landscape, the scale of the project, and current market trends.
Whether the game ultimately gains support depends on whether these conditions come together at the right time.
What Kind of Games Are Investors Looking For?
Gardens was the main case study discussed on the show. According to the guest, the studio—which had already secured several rounds of funding—received an additional investment of approximately $35 million.
Austin believes that to understand this issue, one must first consider the historical context in which it arises. During periods of low interest rates and relatively abundant capital, a project with a reasonable scope and a credible team may find it relatively easy to secure startup funding. However, as the capital environment tightens, projects that have not yet been completed must once again demonstrate why they are worth continuing to invest in.
Therefore, the fact that Gardens continues to attract investment at least indicates that it has been able to demonstrate sufficiently convincing progress and future potential to investors. However, securing additional investment and winning player approval are still two distinct stages.
Gardens' description of the project is also quite interesting. The team used the term “Strandbox” to emphasize the impact players leave on the world: the things you’ve done will be felt by those who come after you; even if you’ve never met, a connection may still be formed.
This reminded the guests of *Death Stranding*, *Journey*, and *Sky: Light Encounters*. These games showcase the potential of a multiplayer experience: exploration, helping others, chance encounters, and shared experiences—all of which are appealing in their own right.
*Sky: Children of the Light* is particularly significant. It demonstrates that large-scale games built around low-barrier interaction and social connections can attract a broad audience. For investors, such examples make an unfamiliar creative direction easier to understand and provide a benchmark for its commercial potential.
Whether a project can secure funding often hinges on this connection: developers propose an experience, and investors find reasons to believe in it by looking at existing examples.
Why Are Mid-Budget Projects in a Tough Spot?
During the show, Austin mentioned that he has observed funding preferences shifting toward the two extremes: on one end, low-cost projects with budgets ranging from approximately $200,000 to $800,000; on the other, projects worth tens of millions of dollars with significant growth potential. He described the mid-range budget segment between these two extremes as a “desert.”
This is a professional’s judgment based on experience, but it highlights a noteworthy issue: the amount of funding a project requires will, in and of itself, influence the type of investors it can attract.
Investments in small projects are relatively limited, allowing investors to undertake low-cost experiments. Although large projects carry higher risks, they may offer the potential for greater returns. Medium-sized projects, however, face a difficult question: When they already require a significant amount of resources, are the expected returns sufficient to justify the investment?
For independent developers, this means that budget planning and funding strategies must be considered together. In addition to calculating the costs required to complete the game, the team must also understand which investors are willing to support a project of this scale and what results those investors expect to see.
Within the publisher, you need someone to champion your game
Developers tend to think of publishers as a scoring system: they input their team’s background, market data, budget, and a demo, and ultimately receive an investment decision.
The program reminds us that it is people who actually make the decisions.
A publisher may only sign a handful of projects in a given year. Decision-makers must consider market conditions, but they are also influenced by their own experience, aesthetic preferences, and judgment. One person might identify a player demographic that their colleagues have not yet recognized, or have greater confidence in a particular gameplay mechanic, and thus be willing to advocate for the project internally to secure funding.
This role is that of an internal advocate for the project.
Austin compares fundraising to the process of seeking patrons during the Renaissance. Developers need to find people who understand the direction of their project, appreciate the team’s culture, and are willing to take risks. Within publishing companies and investment firms, this person must also be able to convey their judgment to other decision-makers.
This places higher demands on roadshows. A good presentation must not only help the audience understand the project but also enable them to clearly explain to their colleagues—even after leaving the meeting room—why this game is worth supporting.
The more vague a vision is, the harder it is for its supporters to secure resources for it.
Beyond market data, there is also the ever-changing investment narrative
Investors need a basis for their decisions, but the gaming market rarely provides complete information.
The program noted that, in the past, sales statistics from the retail market provided a relatively clear picture of the market. Today, however, vast amounts of data are held internally by platforms and companies, and publicly available information tends to focus on sales milestones worth celebrating. As a result, it is difficult for outside observers to accurately determine exactly how many successful players there are in a given market segment—and how many projects have failed to meet expectations.
In such an environment, success stories become key tools for interpreting the market.
When cooperative games perform exceptionally well, investors may begin to focus on the demand for “players wanting to play with friends.” When competitive games become popular, investors may further envision esports growing into a major sports industry.
There is a gap here that is easily bridged: the evidence required to demonstrate that players enjoy a certain experience is not the same as the evidence needed to support the high expectations of rewards built around that experience.
This is where the guests’ reflections on the esports investment boom come into play. The demand may be real, but the scale of the investment requires investors to believe in a much brighter future. Capital needs to find a place to go, and it will actively seek out narratives that are compelling enough to justify the investment.
For developers, understanding these stories helps with communicating project details; at the same time, it’s important to distinguish between insights derived from player behavior and those that are merely expectations for the future.
Why Even Excellent Teams Can Still Fail
A team's track record is a key factor for investors in evaluating a project. Team members who have been involved in successful projects typically find it easier to build trust. However, talent can only increase the chances of success.
Even talented developers can be led astray. A project may struggle to find its core experience for a long time, or it may gradually lose the features that initially made it appealing as it continually seeks to reach a broader audience.
The program discussed a situation that warrants particular caution: a team that continues to refine existing content without reevaluating the project’s direction. As time and resources are continually poured into the game, making it increasingly polished, the fundamental issue of its appeal remains unresolved.
Therefore, team evaluations must also focus on decision-making processes. Who is responsible for setting the direction? How is player feedback incorporated into the development process? When existing content fails to deliver the expected experience, does the team have the ability to make adjustments?
These issues determine whether the team can apply its capabilities in the right areas.
Funding increasingly requires proof of concept.
Austin's advice to independent developers is quite straightforward: clearly describe what the game is, explain what makes it special, and then show a clip of it in action.
Prototypes and vertical slices are important because they bridge the gap between language and experience.
“Players will naturally cooperate” is a hypothesis. Only when investors see with their own eyes how players cooperate, why they are willing to cooperate, and what happens as a result of that cooperation does it begin to constitute evidence.
Of course, a creative vision doesn’t have to take the form of a fully developed mechanic right from the start. It may originate from a certain atmosphere, an artistic style, or a feeling the team hopes players will experience. But as the project progresses, the team needs to gradually identify gameplay mechanics that can bring these ideas to life and allow others to experience them.
A valuable prototype should be able to address the project’s most critical uncertainty: Does this experience work?
How to Strike a Balance Between the Market and Creativity
The overview of Gardens' funding round also raises another question: To what extent should developers adjust their projects based on market conditions?
The program noted that early descriptions of the project emphasized online gameplay, PvPvE, fantasy adventure, sandbox elements, and action RPG mechanics, while later descriptions placed greater emphasis on connections, chance encounters, and the impact players leave behind. Based on this wording alone, it’s impossible to determine exactly how much the game has actually changed, but it illustrates a reality of fundraising communications: the same project can be presented to investors from different angles.
Austin believes that independent game development typically begins with a core vision. This vision might be the gameplay, the aesthetic, or the player experience. Around this core, the surrounding design gradually takes shape and evolves, while also being adjusted based on funding and development conditions.
Some investors may request that a game more closely align with a certain genre, while some developers may proactively seek changes they are willing to accept. The key is that the team needs to know which aspects are negotiable and which ones underpin the project’s raison d’être.
If you don’t even understand this much, every adjustment made during the fundraising process could push the project further away from its original goals.
Why Do Players Need Your Game?
The program used a simple premise to illustrate what market positioning ultimately aims to answer:
Minecraft already lets players build with blocks. If your game lets players build with circles, why would anyone play it?
The formal differences are easy to describe, but the value players experience requires further explanation. Does the circular shape create new ways of building? Does it offer different challenges, forms of expression, or social experiences? Why can’t existing games provide these things?
This issue also brought the entire discussion on fundraising back to the game itself.
Investors may be drawn in by the team’s track record, convinced by market trends, or filled with anticipation for a certain future. But ultimately, developers still need to explain: Who would want to play this game, why would they be willing to invest their time in it, and what evidence has the team already provided?
Historical sales data can help inform decisions, but it cannot fully predict new experiences. Personal trust can support innovation, but it can also lead to bias. Independent game funding always requires navigating these uncertainties.
For developers, what they can actively work on is articulating their vision clearly, creating the most essential aspects of the user experience, and then finding people who are willing to understand it. That way, when funding actually comes along, the team will have the opportunity to show investors a game that’s taking shape.
评论
暂无评论