Machine translated · For reference only
Indie Game Funding Has Changed: Why You Now Need to Prove Yourself Before You Can Talk About Money
Russell · 文化与观点
In the past, indie game teams could convince publishers that a game was worth investing in based on nothing more than a proposal. Now, many publishers want to see a gameplay trailer, a Steam page, a wishlist entry, or even a nearly finished version of the game first.
This does not mean that indie games have lost their funding opportunities; rather,Developers need to take on more of the upfront work before investors are willing to assume the subsequent risks.. In Gaming Playbook Interview with Pontus Maehler (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7JH3tNDJgQU)In the article, this consultant—who has long been involved in game publishing, financing, and transaction negotiations—explains why the market has changed and how small teams should respond.
Why Is It Getting Harder and Harder to Make Money?
To understand the changes in indie game financing, we must first look at how investors recoup their investments.
If an investor purchases equity in a studio, eventually someone will typically need to acquire the company or buy out the investor’s shares. The problem is that even if an independent studio successfully releases its first game, it may not immediately become an acquisition target. It may take three or four years for the first game to be released; if sales are lackluster, the team will have to continue developing the next title, which could extend the investor’s exit timeline to six or seven years—or even longer.
At the same time, investors and publishers took on considerable risks during the previous market cycle. Some teams that secured large investments failed to launch their games as planned; others saw their games generate insufficient revenue after launch to support the next phase of development. These outcomes have made investors more cautious and led them to place greater emphasis on observable progress and market response.
Therefore, Pontus offers a word of caution to developers looking to expand their studios: **Don’t base your entire business plan on the assumption that “you’ll definitely secure equity funding next.”** Equity financing may still happen, but for small teams centered around a single game, seeking funding for a specific project often better aligns with the goals of both parties.
A proposal alone is hardly enough to prove a game's viability.
Pontus describes the threshold for securing a publishing deal as a line that has gradually shifted backward: in the early years, a written proposal might have been enough; later, a prototype or demo was required; and more recently, a vertical slice capable of fully demonstrating the core experience has been needed. Today, some publishers want games to be developed further while also seeing evidence of interest on Steam’s Wishlist, community engagement, or other forms of market validation.
The logic behind this isn’t complicated. A project proposal outlines what the team wants to do; a prototype demonstrates whether a particular gameplay mechanic is viable; and a vertical slice further shows what the game is actually like to play, whether the team can integrate its various components, and what level of quality the final product might achieve. Wishlists and community feedback allow publishers to make an initial assessment of whether, aside from the development team itself, there are players who are interested in the game.
For developers, this means they must start preparing for funding well in advance. Setting up a store page, showcasing the game, and gathering player feedback shouldn’t be left until development is complete. Pontus suggests that teams with the resources should focus on promoting their project after completing a vertical slice: at this stage, the game is easier to evaluate, and teams are typically in a stronger position to negotiate.
However, the notion that “the later in development, the easier it is to negotiate” also creates practical pressures: teams must shoulder more of the upfront costs themselves. Therefore, the key is not to wait until the game is nearly finished before reaching out to investors, but rather to find, based on cash reserves,Something that demonstrates the project's value without depleting the team's fundsThe timing of the promotion.
Understanding Contracts: A 50/50 Split May Not Take Effect for a Long Time
When you receive a publishing offer, the revenue-sharing percentage is what tends to catch your attention the most; however, other factors besides this percentage also play a key role in determining your earnings.When does this take effect?..
In an interview, Pontus described a common arrangement: After a game is released, the publisher initially receives 80% to 100% of the revenue until it recoups the investment specified in the contract; after that, the two parties split the revenue 50/50. Specific percentages vary by project, but this example illustrates that simply hearing “50-50 in the end” is far from sufficient.
Developers need to figure out at least three things.
First, **What costs can the publisher recoup?** Are development costs, marketing expenses, and localization costs all included in the recoupment amount? Who determines these expenses? Is there a cap? Can developers view the breakdown? If the scope of recoupment continues to expand, the revenue-sharing arrangement for the next phase specified in the contract may be delayed indefinitely.
Second,What type of income is used to calculate the revenue share?“Total revenue” and “net revenue” may sound like they differ by just one character, but how platform fees, refunds, taxes, and other deductions are handled can all affect the final figure. The more vague the definition, the more likely it is to lead to disputes down the road.
Third, **If the game is successful, will the revenue split be adjusted?** Pontus advocates for establishing a tiered structure in the contract in advance: for example, once the publisher recoups its investment and earns the agreed-upon return, the developer’s share would increase further. Publishers need to profit from successful projects, and developers need the incentive to continue updating and maintaining the game; the long-term work undertaken by both parties should be reflected in long-term revenue.
These terms cannot be evaluated in isolation from the project itself. If a publisher covers most of the development budget and continues to handle marketing and operations, the transaction structure should naturally differ from that of an investor who merely provides a lump-sum investment. Who will cover the costs of future updates, additional language localizations, and porting to other console platforms should also be part of the negotiations. For this reason, Pontus strongly recommends that developers have a lawyer familiar with the gaming industry review the contract before signing any major agreements.
Besides the publisher, what other sources of funding are there?
Another path that was repeatedly mentioned in the interviews isProject Financing: An investor funds a specific game and receives a return from the game’s revenue as agreed. This differs from equity financing, as the focus is on cash returns from the project itself; compared to a publishing partnership, the project investor is not necessarily responsible for marketing, channel management, or ongoing operations.
This distinction directly affects the quote. If two companies offer similar terms for payback and revenue sharing, but one handles distribution and promotion while the other only provides funding, the developer will need to factor in the additional service costs associated with the latter. The team can handle these tasks on its own or hire separate marketing or distribution service providers, but it should not assume that funding will automatically solve all issues after the game’s launch.
In addition, Pontus mentioned opportunities such as platform agreements, regional subsidies, tax incentives, and joint investments by banks. While not every team can access these channels—and eligibility varies by region—they demonstrate that fundraising doesn’t have to be limited to “selling company equity.” A more practical approach is to list potential funding sources based on the project budget, separately accounting for costs, obligations, and the timing of funds receipt.
Don't just focus on familiar markets
Just because a game is sold worldwide doesn't mean players in every region will naturally discover it, understand it, and enjoy it.
Pontus spoke specifically about the Chinese market. His advice is not to simply translate the game into Chinese and look for partners just before launch, but to have people familiar with the local market evaluate the game as early as possible. If local distribution or marketing support is needed, it’s best to begin reaching out about six months before the planned launch to allow time for market assessment, localization, and promotion.
He also pointed out that,The share of sales cannot be directly equated with the share of revenue.. Game prices vary by region, and costs such as platform fees and refunds must also be factored in. Even if a particular market generates significant sales, the net revenue per game may be lower than in the team’s primary market, with which they are familiar. The decision on whether to allocate marketing budget should be based on a more comprehensive revenue projection, rather than solely on the number of potential players.
More broadly speaking, developers can ask themselves: In which regions might this game have players? Where does it need to be localized? Where else might the marketing approach need to be adjusted? If the team lacks relevant experience, finding a trusted local partner may be a safer bet than allocating the budget based solely on their own judgment.
Study the players, rather than chasing the hottest genres of the moment
When it becomes harder to secure funding, teams often find themselves wondering, “What kind of game should we make now to appeal to publishers?”
Pontus remains cautious about this. Game development often takes a long time; themes that are popular today may have lost their appeal by the time the game is released. Rather than chasing trends, it’s more reliable to identifyWhich players consistently enjoy a particular gameplay mechanic?, and how their game preparation meets those needs.
For example, the team can research what other games players of similar titles purchase, what kinds of looping experiences they enjoy, and what their expectations are regarding the game’s polish. This kind of research not only aids in the design process but also enables the team to more clearly explain who the target audience is during pitches.
Market research doesn’t mean accepting every piece of feedback at face value. The opinions of testers, publishers, and investors are all worth listening to, but the team still needs to determine which feedback points to real obstacles and which opinions are merely individual preferences. If the game gradually loses its core experience in an effort to please everyone, it may also lose the very reason that initially attracted players.
The most effective promotion is showing people the progress you've made.
Toward the end of the interview, Pontus offered a very specific suggestion:Don't spend all your limited time and money attending events and showing the same version to different publishers.
Suppose a team pitches its game to twenty publishers at an event, and ten of them point out similar issues. In this case, it’s usually more valuable to return to the studio, determine why these issues arose, and improve the game—rather than rushing off to the next event to repeat the same presentation. When the team follows up a few months later, it should be able to demonstrate clear improvements.
He suggested including a concise one-page update log with the resubmitted version: what changes have been made since the last communication, how much actual development time was spent, how much funding was used, and which milestones were achieved. If the team is simultaneously working on other projects, resulting in only one month out of the three being available for development, this should also be clearly stated. Otherwise, the evaluators might mistakenly assume that the team devoted the full three calendar months to the project.
The purpose of this report is not merely to explain progress. Publishers and investors receive a large number of projects,Improvements Between the Two Encounters...and it also serves as evidence for them to determine whether the team can carry out the plan.
We need to keep the studio afloat first—only then will we have a chance to make a great game.
When the market is tough, “continuing development” is a business challenge in and of itself. Pontus suggests that small teams facing financial constraints might consider taking on co-development projects to maintain their staff and cash flow, thereby buying time to work on their own games. This may not be what founders originally set out to do, but it could give the project a chance to be completed.
His central argument can be summarized as three consecutive questions:Has the game proven to be worth continuing to invest in? How far can the team go with its current funding? Once it reaches that milestone, who would be the best source for the next round of funding?
Changes in indie game funding require developers to understand both players and business terms at an earlier stage. Great games still have a chance to secure support; however, today, a game’s vision must gradually evolve into a plan that investors are willing to back—through a playable version, genuine market feedback, and credible progress reports.
评论
暂无评论